Santa Ana: Community Forum On Council Districts Tomorrow, April 26

While most Orange County cities elect their councils at-large, and several have moved to by-district elections under the litigation gun, two cities – Santa Ana and Newport Beach – elected their city councils via a mixed system: candidates must live in and run from a geographic voting district, but are voted on city-wide (this is how most school districts elected their governing boards).

After the Santa Ana police officers union succeeded last November in reducing the council majority of which he is a part, Councilman Sal Tinajero was suddenly disturbed by the power of government unions – are at least this particular union. Earlier this year, he unsuccessfully moved for a shift to by-district elections in hopes of mitigating the police union’s campaign funding muscle.

There are pros and cons to either approach. Under a by-district election system, candidates have to communicate with significantly fewer voters in order to win election. The upshot – in theory, at least – is a candidate can win without a large warchest through grass-roots organizing. However, a serious downside is councilmembers are still governing the entire city but are no longer accountable to the entire city. Citizens are governed by councilmembers in whose election – save one – they have no voice.

Despite the defeat of Tinajero’s motion to consider by-district elections, the issue isn’t dead in Santa Ana. Tomorrow night there will be Election Process Forum 4-26-17 Eng Span on the topic, with Santa Ana resident and businessman Mike Tardif presenting the case for the current system, and Anaheim Councilman Jose Moreno presenting the case for by-district elections:

The city council still has the option of placing the question before the voters, which could also be achieved by a citizens petition drive as happened in San Clemente (where a hostile city council chose to punt the measure until the 2018 ballot rather than the 2016 ballot desired by organizers). Alternatively, the matter could be forced by a California Voting Rights Act (CVRA) lawsuit; there has been talk of such action in OC GOP circles for a few years now. However, the likelihood of a lawsuit from any political quarter is somewhat diminished by a new state law capping attorney fees in CVRA lawsuits at $75,000.

Santa Ana’s population is 78% Latino but its council is 100% Latino (and Democratic). A CVRA lawsuit could flip the progressive script and claim racially-polarized voting deprives the city’s growing Asian (primarily Vietnamese) and white citizens of having their “candidates of choice” elected to the council.

Since the current system skews, in a partisan sense, totally in favor of Latino Democrat candidates, a shift to by-district elections – regardless of the means of achieving it – could well result in the election of one or two Vietnamese-American council members, which would increase the odds of a Republican presence on the council.

You may also like:

May Day In Orange County: Progressive-Left Marches... It was May Day yesterday, and leftists, progressives, union activists marched in the county's two largest cities - Anaheim and Santa Ana. Radical p...
Santa Ana Could Lose Tens of Millions Under Trump ... The Santa Ana City Council was in a headlong rush to pass a "sanctuary city" ordinance prior for Donald Trump's inauguration as president on January 2...
Chaotic City Manager Succession At Santa Ana City ... Mayor Miguel Pulido called an emergency closed session council meeting for Wednesday, December 28 to conduct a review of City Manager David Cavazos - ...
Loading Facebook Comments ...
Loading Disqus Comments ...
Facebook Auto Publish Powered By : XYZScripts.com